• Home
    • About
    • Contact
  • Archives
  • Track & Field
    • 400 meters
    • 800m & Mile
    • 1/2 & Full Marathons
    • Long & Triple Jump
    • Hurdles
  • Training
    • Weight Training
    • Abs & Core
    • Injury Prevention
    • Shoes & Spikes
    • Masters
  • Coaching
    • Freelap Friday Five
    • Interviews
    • Sport Psychology
    • Sports Nutrition
  • STORE

SpeedEndurance.com

Success in Track & Field ... and Life

26
SHARES
FacebookTwitter

Why Handicap Races are Unfair

February 25, 2015 by Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos Leave a Comment

A few days ago Jimson asked me an interesting question that was a variation of a well-known puzzle:

Assume you race against Usain Bolt in the 100 meter sprint. Not surprisingly, Bolt wins the race, and the margin of victory is 10 meters (although if he did race against me, it would be much greater!) He runs a 9.58, and you run 10.58.

In a re-match, if you were to compete with him again, what would happen if you both ran at the same effort as the first time, and:

  • Race1:  You get a 10 meters head start or handicap from the starting line (i.e. you run 90 meters), and Usain Bolt 100m. Or,
  • Race 2:  Usain Bolt starts from 10 meters behind the starting line (i.e. he runs 110 meters, and you run 100m)

Stawell Gift - Why Handicap Races are Unfair

Intuitively, you would probably think that in both of the cases above, you would both cross the finishing line at the same time. It turns out that things are not quite as they seem.

In order to simplify matters, let us assume that Bolt completed the race in his world record time, i.e. 9.58 seconds. So in the initial race, when he crossed the finishing line, you would be left 10 meters behind, having covered just 90 meters. In other words, it takes you 9.58 seconds to cover 90 meters. The last 10m in covered in 1.00 seconds.

Now let us look at the first rematch case. In 9.58 seconds, Usain Bolt will have covered 100 meters and will just be crossing the finishing line. In the same time, you will have covered 90 meters, but as you started off 10 meters ahead of the starting line, you are also just crossing the finishing line. So for the first case, as expected, nobody wins.

In the second case, after 9.58 seconds you will have progressed 90 meters from the starting line. Usain Bolt, on the other hand, will have covered 100 meters and having started from 10 meters behind the starting line will be at the same point as you. So after 9.58 seconds, both you and Usain Bolt are positioned 90 meters from the starting line. Unfortunately for you, however, the race has not finished yet as there are still 10 meters remaining! Since Usain Bolt is a faster runner, he will complete the remaining 10 meters in a faster time than you, so he wins the race! It may be counterintuitive, but the two cases produce a different result.

The set up just described previously is obviously completely imaginary. This whole exercise, however, provides us with the opportunity to ponder a little on a more realistic situation, i.e. those races that athletes are handicapped according to their form. In some cases, for example, a 10 meter head start is offered for each second of difference in time. So if you were competing against Usain Bolt and you had been timed to run the 100 meters in 10.58 seconds, you would be given a 10 meter head start.

There are a few potential pitfalls here.

First of all, for this method to work even approximately, it has to be assumed that every athlete has been running to his or her full ability prior to the main event. If this is not the case, then an overgenerous handicap will be offered placing him or her in an advantageous position.

Furthermore, the method of taking a 1 second difference in time and translating it into a 10 meter difference in distance is, of course, not entirely accurate. (Some races use 1 meter = 0.1 second handicap)

Athletes do not run at a constant speed, as there are an accelerating and a decelerating phase at the start and the end of the sprint. A time difference of 1 second will usually not correlate to EXACTLY 10 meters of difference in the distance covered, thus corresponding handicaps offered will not be entirely fair.

The chart below shows every sprinter’s last 10 meter speed (and time) is different, depending on their ability.  Based on velocity, the last 10 meter split ranges from Usain Bolt’s 0.83 sec to a split of 1.00 sec for a 10.60 sprinter, and finally a split of 1.15 sec for an 11.50 sprinter!

Speed_vs_speedendurance_by_Derek_Hansen.png

Image Credits: Derek Hansen   Twitter: @DerekMHansen

On the other hand, of course, they are many that believe that with all its shortfalls, the handicap system still makes a race much more interesting. The first to cross the line is the true “winner”.

Nothing in sports, or even in life, is entirely fair.

Whatever you may think, one thing is certain. If you do ever get to race Usain Bolt and get offered a handicap, make sure that you choose the shorter distance to run and give him the longer one!

  • Bio
  • Facebook
  • Latest Posts
  • Published Books
Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos

Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos

University Lecturer at Technological Education Institute (TEI) of Central Greece
Dr. Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos graduated from the University of Glasgow (UK), with a joint honours degree in Aerospace and Electronic Engineering, in 1995. The following year he completed a MSc course in Flight Dynamics at Cranfield University (UK). In 2001 he obtained his PhD from the University of Glasgow, conducting research on the validation of a rotorcraft mathematical model by means of flight testing a gyroplane. His research interests include the aerodynamics of sports balls and improving engineering education.
Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos
Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos

Latest posts by Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos (see all)

  • Why Handicap Races are Unfair - February 25, 2015
  • Why Do You Hear the Gun AFTER the Sprinters Leave the Blocks? - February 18, 2015
  • FIFA World Cup – Free Kick Tutorial and Accuracy - June 11, 2014
Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos
Dr. Vassilios McInnes Spathopoulos is the author of An Introduction to the Physics of Sports and Every Night Astronomy: From Ancient Calendars to Harvest Moons

Related

Filed Under: Track & Field

Gymboss Timers
Google+ comment widget by skipser

Follow Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Click here to reveal the mental secrets to go from joking around to world champion

RECENT POSTS

  • SpeedEndurance TV – Back to the Basics of Speed
  • How fast do CrossFit’ers run 400m?
  • Sleep Patterns with the FitBit Alta and FitBit Alta+HR
  • Sprinting Technique: The Key to Increasing your Speed
  • Using a Sprinter’s Breath Hold to Improve Performance
  • How to Lose Weight with the 4S Approach
  • 4 Top Strength Training Type Workouts for Increased Speed
  • 400 Meter Training – A Scientific Approach
  • The Secret to a Good Night Sleep is Knowing your Sleep Patterns
  • Sprinting: 10 Research Articles for Effective Sprint Training [Part 19]

SEARCH OR LOOKUP BY CATEGORY

FIND US ON FACEBOOK

FIND US ON FACEBOOK

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

SpeedEndurance TV

https://www.youtube.com/user/speedendurance/

About Me

Online since 2002, with the addition of the Blog in 2007, SpeedEndurance.com is the book I never wrote with 2000+ articles.
I am a former 200m/400m sprinter, a Masters Athlete and Coach, who has lived in Canada, US, Italy, and now resides in London UK. My other projects include the Bud Winter Foundation, writer for the IAAF New Studies in Athletics Journal (NSA), and a member of the Track & Field Writers of America.

30 Day Free Coaching Program

30 Day Free Coaching Program
Sign up for this Program and you will receive an email every day for the next 30 days with links to over 60 manuals!
Contributors include Clyde Hart, Tom Tellez, Dan Pfaff, Loren Seagrave, Don Chu, plus my free 36 page report on Jamaican Sprint Secrets, with insights to Stephen Francis and Glen Mills

Now Available!

Bud Winter's updated 1963 classic "Rocket Sprint Start" is now available.
The original book with Armin Hary and Dennis Johnson remains intact with an all new update using comparisons with Jamaican Sprinters.
A must read for anyone who coaches events that uses Starting Blocks.
Copyright © 2018. SpeedEndurance.com is owned and operated by Aryta Ltd.
Get FREE Coaching manuals here! Clyde Hart's 60 Page 400 meter training, Stephen Francis, Glen Mills, Tom Tellez, and more!

Sign up for the FREE monthly Newsletter today and receive Clyde Hart's new 60 page manual on Sprints and Relays AND the 36 page Jamaican Sprint Secrets with insights to Stephen Francis and Glen Mills... the coaches of Asafa Powell & Usain Bolt!.

You'll also get coaching manuals from Tom Tellez, Loren Seagrave and Dan Pfaff.

Want more? How about Lee Evans famous "Train with Pain" 400 meter training from Stan Dowell?

We respect your email privacy

Open Close
Podcast powered by podPress v8.8.10.17