• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Click here to download the  free ebook of Alberto Juantorena’s  detailed training workouts leading up to the 1976 Montreal Olympics

SpeedEndurance.com

Success in Track & Field ... and Life

  • Home
    • About
    • Contact
  • Track & Field
    • 400 meters
    • 800m & Mile
    • 1/2 & Full Marathons
    • Long & Triple Jump
    • Hurdles
  • Training
    • Weight Training
    • Abs & Core
    • Injury Prevention
    • Shoes & Spikes
    • Masters
  • Coaching
    • Freelap Friday Five
    • Interviews
    • Sports Nutrition
    • Sport Psychology
  • Archives
  • Shop
    • My account
    • Checkout
    • Basket

Has the 10,000 hour “Rule” been Debunked?

You are here: Home / Coaching / Has the 10,000 hour “Rule” been Debunked?
17
SHARES
FacebookTwitter

August 31, 2014 by Jimson Lee Leave a Comment

Last Updated on April 26, 2015 by Jimson Lee

A recent study has been carried out which has supposedly debunked the whole purposeful practise ‘rule’ is now doing the rounds. I saw it on the Science of Sport Facebook page under the heading RULE “simply does not exist”.

I followed their link to an article in The Smithsonian Mag called The 10,000 hour rule is not real: The biggest meta-analysis of research to date indicates that practice does not make perfect.

10000 hour rule

This article ends with

“So despite the new evidence that the 10,000 hour rule is bull, like the studies and articles that came before it, that message will likely fall on deaf ears. The 10,000 hour rule seems to have entered into the common lore about success: it’s a nice idea, that hard work will actually pay off. And no peer reviewed study so far succeeded in toppling that catchy message.”

So in the first instance, I immediately rail against someone attempting to prevent a debate in the way that Rachel Nuwar did in the last paragraph of the Smithsonian article. It basically says, that if you believe the 10,000 hour rule, it is equivalent of believing the earth is flat.

I recently wrote an article reviewing The Sports Gene by David Epstein and in that I wrote:

I saw the 10,000-hour rule for what it was. A construct to tell people that if they wanted to get to the top, they had to really graft and grind. Not just a little bit but almost beyond the imagining of most people. Roughly speaking; 10 years, 1000 hours a year, 20 hours a week. It is an enormous number, but people need to recognise it. It doesn’t matter if you get to the other end and find that you took 7 years or 13 years or whatever. When you start out, that is a long way away and the tolerance is irrelevant in the beginning. 10,000 hours is as good a hook as any to hang the deliberate practice hat on and it works for me as a coach.

But I’ve read the whole of the study and even though the conclusions that the three scientists draw from it are very clear, for them, but, as a coach, I read their report differently to what they did. Here is what they say:

Their claim that individuals differences in performance are largely accounted for by individual differences in amount of deliberate practice is not supported by available empirical evidence.

I will say that their research was exhaustive. I can’t argue with the data they’ve collected. It is impressive. So what did I see that they didn’t?

See also  9.77 seconds - 100 Meter World Record revisited

In their study, they found that in Sports, taking a total variance in performance equal to 100%, the amount attributable to deliberate practise was 18% and the other 82% was unexplained. In my world, the 82% is art. It is the art of coaching, it is all the things that make up an athlete, whether it be genetic differences described by Epstein or anything really. But 18% variance because of deliberate practice? Not only does this not debunk the deliberate practice theories, it even contradicts what they conclude.

Nobody really counts the 10,000 hours as I said above. It is just a big number, like 40 days and 40 nights just means ‘a long time’. The problem I have with these sensationalist articles is that people start to believe that ‘practise does not make perfect’. (They are right of course, practise makes permanent; perfect practise makes perfect). The logical conclusion that some people draw is that practise therefore is not that important. Now that is bull and not only is it being espoused by Miss Nuwar, it is then propagated by sites such as The Science of Sport. If it has science in the title it must be true right?

As a coach, fractions of a percentage are important. Let me give you an example, using my poor son again. He is 17 years old. His 400m PB right now is 47.94. Exactly 10% improvement would see him take the World record by 3/100 second. So, 18%? I’d take that just fine!

The truth however is that every coach and athlete knows that deliberate practice is significant and so everyone is deliberately practising as hard as they can, which levels the playing field, despite what the so called experts and scientists conclude or sensationalise.

See also  Justin Gatlin - Batman or Robbing?

About the Author

LeeNess-bookcover250x350

My name is Lee Ness. I am a UKA qualified Event Group Coach for Sprints and Hurdles, the Head Coach/Sprint Coach at City of Salisbury Athletics and Running Club and Track and Field Team Manager for Wiltshire Athletics Association. I’ve been coaching track and filed for around 7 years. I coach all the sprints, from 60m to 400m plus the long and sprint hurdles. In my sprint group I have 36 sprinters and 10 hurdlers of various ages, starting from 13. In my group I have three athletes in the UK top 10 rankings for their event.

I write about sports performance in general and have written a book called The Sports Motivation Masterplan which will be released on September 1, 2014 by December House. The book is a support guide for athletes and parents, helping them with the role of mentor through their journey from young aspiring athlete, to elite performer.

Category iconCoaching,  Sport Psychology,  Success,  Track & Field Tag iconLee Ness

About Jimson Lee

I am a Masters Athlete and Coach currently based in London UK. My other projects include the Bud Winter Foundation, writer for the IAAF New Studies in Athletics Journal (NSA) and a member of the Track & Field Writers of America.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Recommended

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xbs-aWxyLk

Shop Our Store

  • Bud Winter (9)
  • Championship Productions (6)
  • Clyde Hart (2)
  • Derek Hansen (1)
  • Electrical Muscle Stimulation (2)
  • Jim Hiserman (6)
  • Jimson Lee (4)
  • Uncategorised (0)

Articles by Category

Products

  • Jim Hiserman - Developing 800m Runners: Identifying, Categorizing and Developing 400m-800m Type Athletes $42.99 $39.99
  • Private Coaching - Monthly Plan $600.00 $525.00
  • Jim Hiserman-Developing-Distance-Runnersv2 Jim Hiserman - Developing Distance Runners Volume 2: A Systematic Approach to Developing Individual Success within a Dynamic Team Culture $34.95 $29.95
  • Feed-the-Cats-Clinic-3-Pack-701 'Feed the Cats' Clinic 3-Pack $64.99
  • Tony Holler's Feed the Cats": A Complete Sprint Training Program Tony Holler's "Feed the Cats" Complete Sprint Training Program $49.99
  • Bud Winter and Speed City presents Arthur Lydiard 509x716 Bud Winter & Arthur Lydiard MP3 [Download only] $9.99

RECENT POSTS

  • Oregon22 Coaches Club now Online
  • IFAC 2022: The Return of In-Person Conferences (with Virtual option)
  • Here is our 400m Discussion Recording… over 2 Hours Long
  • The Best Free Coaching Book – post Beijing 2022 Olympics
  • The Ultimate 400m Track Webinar for Coaches & Athletes
  • NACAC Athletics Coaching Science Series 2022
  • Top Six 400m Predictor Workouts (Number 4 is my Favourite)
  • Best 6 Podcasts for 2021 (and Beyond)
  • Why Karsten Warholm’s 45.94 400mH WR is my Highlight of 2021
  • Sprinting: 10 Research Articles for Effective Sprint Training [Part 23]

Copyright © 2023. SpeedEndurance.com is owned and operated by Aryta Ltd. Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}